Reaction to Blair's speech: mawkish melodrama or well deserved praise?

Ok, ok. Blair has delivered his last ever conference speech as Prime Minister to the Labour Party, and perhaps as Simon Heffer argued, his first as a historical figure. Having read the speech it is truly inspiring and that of a leading, experienced statesman. However, the Comment in today's press is utterly remarkable. Never underestimate the potential of the British media to be unapologetically fickle. True, we mustn't deny credit where credit's due or shackle ourselves to our personal biases alone, but at the same time the balance shouldn't be tipped too far the other way either.

I myself hold dear with what Simon Heffer articulated in today's Telegraph, 27/09/06 "A mistake made over the years by opponents of Mr Blair has been to impute cynicism to his every act and motive, and to ignore his positive qualities because of dissatisfaction with his policies". Whether you're a skeptic or not, or even at odds at Blair's policies, it is important to separate personal prejudices from the achievements of the person.

My point is that the press appears to have gone AWOL and been replaced with mawkish idolatry. Have a look at what's in today's print on Blair's speech. Ranked in order of conviction, glance over the clarion of star struck praise - even The Telegraph couldn't resist indulging in the hysteria.


THE GUARDIAN on Blair

Leader: "majestic", "elegant and emotional explanation", "they will miss him"

Polly Toynbee: "political genius", "eloquence", "clever charm", "ache of nostalgia", "political stardust"

Jonathan Freedland: "anxious about losing him", "political performer", "moves effortlessly from light to shade", "panache at the podium", "sorcerer's powers"


THE TIMES on Blair

Leader: "artistry of a political master whose powers are undiminished", "impressive", "flare"

Alice Miles: "a sprinkle of stardust over a lacklustre conference", "confident", "enthusiastic", "uncompromising"


THE TELEGRAPH on Blair

Leader: "sharp in political critique", "humanly engaging", "witty", "sufficiently original", "genuinely interesting", "perceptive"

Simon Heffer: "looked naturally authentic", "plausible", "honest", "accomplished"



A little over the top I think you'll agree - not to diminish Blair's achievements however you interpret them.

To see the speech go the politics section of The Guardian or the BBC News Website.